Thank you. The ballet suggestion will work, I hope, since I also need room for my toes.

The good news is that slingbacks continue to be in style, and they give you that sandal look without exposing the toes. Something like this slingback, maybe in the gold or warm white would look very summery and fresh. Or you could do this woven ballet-inspired flat with the capped toe. Again, it gives you the feel and look of a sandal, but conceals the toes. There are lots of other similar options out there, so keep your eyes open for textured, woven shoes that expose some of the foot, but not the toes. Both of those come in wide sizes.